Compare
EditWithChat vs Submagic
Submagic and EditWithChat both turn a talking-head clip into a captioned short. One is a subscription in the cloud. The other is $49 on your Mac.
Submagic adds animated captions, B-roll, zooms and music to short-form video. You upload the clip, pick a caption style, and download the result. It is a subscription.
EditWithChatSubmagic
Price$49 onceSubscription, with a free try
Where it runsOn your MacIn the browser. The clip is uploaded
Captions, zooms, B-rollYes, from the template you pickYes, from their caption styles
Then whatType a change. Every version is keptRegenerate or adjust in their editor
A reel you lovePaste a link and that edit becomes a templateYou pick from their styles
Your footageStays on your MacUploaded to make the edit
Choose EditWithChat if
You want that kind of finished short, on your own Mac, for one payment, and you want to copy a specific reel rather than pick a caption preset.
Choose Submagic if
You want a browser tool you can try on a clip today, and you are fine paying monthly and uploading the footage.
Other products change their prices and features. This describes the kind of tool Submagic is, as of November 2026, not a quote.